Episode 1

Constables Tom Coffin and Stephen Rodden attend the Commodore Hotel in Penetanguishene, where they run into a man Coffin had arrested a year prior for a DUI; the man shoots Coffin in the back of the head, devastating an entire community.

Episode 2

Stepanie Hoddinott's ex-boyfriend Jacob Ferrier wants to get back with her; upon Stephanie's denial, Jacob shoots and kills her, and then himself; the case rocks the small community of Midland, Ontario.

Episode 3

Susanna Balogh, her boyfriend, and a friend keep Katlin captive in their farmhouse basement and eventually set the house on fire to cover the crime; the story haunts the citizens of Midland, Ontario.

Episode 4

After leaving a party, 18-year old Jake Just decides to take a shortcut through the woods of Sunnyside in Midland, Ontario, never to be seen again.

Episode 5

After leaving a party, 18-year old Jake Just decides to take a shortcut through the woods of Sunnyside in Midland, Ontario, never to be seen again.